Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ha. Your answer was technically correct but completely useless. Implicit in Animats' question was when that whole process happens.


The FDA does not have the power to jail people. Determining whether the state has sufficient reason to incarnate individuals is responsibility of the justice system. People go to jail when a judge and or jury recon thats justified. The FDA will make its case when it believes it has one.

Will anyone from a 10B startup go to jail ? Probably not, but we can schedule that for afternoon tea outrage.


Again, you're spouting Civics 101 answers here. I'm familiar with how the US justice system operates. The question isn't looking for that. The FDA obviously won't have an FDA Judge send people to FDA Jail after they've been arrested by the FDA Police. Literally nobody here thinks that.

But they do initiate investigations, and it is a crime to defraud or attempt to defraud the FDA. And if the FDA so chooses, they can forward their information to Justice and participate in the proceedings against the accused. They could provide the evidence of wrongdoing and increase the political pressure to act. They can do a lot to ensure that the state determines it has sufficient reason.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: