I thought that "stock return" is the [exit price]/[entry price], for an asset that does not pay dividends, no? exit/entry still requires a log() to be normally distributed, for example exit/entry is non-negative, wile gaussian is of course sometimes negative, no matter what the mean is.
Itβs clear that then the mean return is the dividends paid and can be negative if the exit price is sufficiently low. I think by a bit of squinting (using the central limit theorem) you can say that this should be normally distributed as long as entry_price and exit_price have the same distribution
Coming back to options world, entry_price is a constant when opening the contract, let's ignore dividends, the formula is (exit_price - entry_price) / entry_price = exit_price/entry_price - 1 = exit_price/constant - 1.
This is normally distributed if, and only if exit_price is normally distributed. You'd want to to add back the 1, log() it, add back the log(constant) to cancel it out and just work on the log(exit_price) normally distributed random variable.
Stock return really is not normally distributed. Log(stock return) is normally distributed (under B-S, it's an assumption after all). Stock return is log-normally distributed. Multiply by 1/entry_price and subtract 1 to get your version of stock returns.
[0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/blackscholes.asp