Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I generally agree. That said, we tried the personal responsibility route, and then the bars packed up for St. Patrick's day and the airports ended up becoming giant petri dishes - literally overnight. And then many, many, many people decided that "don't panic" meant somewhere between clear all the shelves at every store and ignore the problem until it goes away.

I don't envy the local governments trying to contain this with almost no data and no help or direction from the federal government.



Well I am equally not sure why it is federal governments responsibility to help and direct

In our system of government the State Governments are suppose to be the most powerful, not the federal government

it is a Union of States after all.

The fact that in the last 100 years or so we continually have centralized more and more power into the hands of the federal government is a huge issue, but instead of recognizing that issue people seeming want to put more and more power federally and continue to strip their local governments of power

The smaller the unit of power the faster it can react to local changes. In situations like this it SHOULD be local government leading the charge not a slow monolithic federal government


That's fair, but this is exactly the sort of issue that needs to be orchestrated at a higher level. If Illinois handles this perectly somehow, but the surrounding states do not, then Illinois' efforts will be wasted and overcome by the neighbors. There's no way this sort of problem will be resolved without the entire country being on the same page for the solution. That's exactly the sort of thing the federal government is good for.


I am pretty sure we are going to disagree widely was to what "sorted out the problem" looks like in execution

Especially if you think Illinois is a model everyone should be following


I'm pretty sure you're aware that was hypothetical.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: