Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Searching the page for "liberal" gives 41 hits, searching for "economist" gives 42 hits. It's very hard to take the article seriously even after reading just the first sentence:

> The publication has a sublime — even smug — self-confidence in its elite liberal worldview.

What ever they're proposing may very well have merit, but in that tone, there's little interest to hear the case out.



As a subscriber to the Economist, I fully concur with the line you take offense with. It is very self-assured in its worldview. Pointing that out should not be controversial.


Yes, the fact that Economist has an obvious political stand should not be taken as a bug - it's a feature. Their fact-based journalism is excellent, and when they take a stand on an issue, it's obvious and not hidden inside some fake statistics or pseudoscience.


As a sometime-reader I find the clear worldview refreshing. While clearly CNN has a particular worldview, they constantly try to remind people that they don't hold that worldview, in order to convince people they are impartial. Same goes for basically any media, the different is between if it's clear or if they are trying to seem impartial while not being so.

I'd much rather news organizations be clear about their view, so I as a reader can keep that in mind and also look at the opposition view, because that other news organization would also be clear that they do hold the opposition view.


It's what frustrates me whenever I read an Economist piece. Their absolute certainty in declaring what should be done about any particular topic is jarring. The 'pretend you are God' line in the article is exactly the problem.


But that is the exact description of the tone the magazine uses in its opinion pieces. Unlike most of the news outlets, they don't confuse facts with opinions. You know exactly which type of article you are reading thanks to that tone.


The person writting the article doesn't really know what the word sublime means for a start.


Well, I wouldn't be so quick with the accusations. One of the Cambridge Dictionary's example sentences for the word sublime is He possesses sublime self-confidence: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/sublime




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: