Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why? Factually they are...

Case in point.. I used to run game servers for maybe over 1000+ guilds over the years I was active. Even talking 10 years ago, people were still using Skype for connecting to games... just because it doesn't fit your use-case doesn't mean the market wasn't competing.

IRC was also in the space. Look at the dozens+ IRC servers which had communities built around them... they've mostly migrated to Discord.

I'd love to know your counter point to such an absolute-claim though... because I positively agree with the author.



I think we might have different definitions of competition. As of July 2020, Discord had over 100-million monthly users. At last count, netsplit.de reports 360k IRC "users". That's not even 1% of the Discord user base and it's shrinking every year. No new significant IRC communities have emerged in at least a decade because it's a dying protocol while Discord adds millions of users every month. Yes, IRC is an alternative to Discord but it's not a competitor (to Discord, or any other protocol) by any stretch of the imagination.


IRC is used far beyond freenode and official IRC servers. IRC was used as the chat backend of Twitch, among lot of public unix servers -internally-.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: