Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So what was the deal with the Scottish flag?


From Wikipedia:

> A separate mechanism (emoji tag sequences) is used for regional flags, such as England 󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿, Scotland 󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿, Wales 󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿, Texas 󠁵󠁳󠁴󠁸󠁿 or California 󠁵󠁳󠁣󠁡󠁿. It uses U+1F3F4 WAVING BLACK FLAG and formatting tag characters instead of regional indicator symbols. It is based on ISO 3166-2 regions with hyphen removed and lowercase, e.g. GB-ENG → gbeng, terminating with U+E007F CANCEL TAG. Flag of England is therefore represented by a sequence U+1F3F4, U+E0067, U+E0062, U+E0065, U+E006E, U+E0067, U+E007F.


This was the only part that was surprising to me, and as it turns out my surprise mostly stems from still not really understanding how the United Kingdom works.


I was born and raised in the UK and I still can't explain to people how it works. Are England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland separate countries? Is the UK a country? It's countries all the way down.


The UK is an unitary state with 3 autonomous areas that have different devolved levels of self-governance, similar to Italy or (in theory) China.

The difficult part comes from calling these autonomous areas "countries".


Don't worry, "How the United Kingdom works" is a political question and so subject to change.

For example, Wales was essentially just straight up conquered, and so for long periods Wales did not have any distinct legal identity from England. You'll see that today there's a bunch of laws which are for England and Wales but notably not Scotland, including criminal laws. In living memory Wales got some measure of independent control over its own affairs, via an elected "Assembly" but what powers are "devolved" to this assembly are in effect the gift of the Parliament, in Westminster, which is sovereign. Whether taking away those powers would go well is a good question.

On the other hand, Northern Ireland is what's left of English/ British dominion over the entire island of Ireland, most of which today is the Republic of Ireland, a sovereign entity with its own everything. It's only existed for about a century, and is a result of the agreed "partition" when the Irish rebelled because most of the Irish wanted independence but those in the North not so much. Feel free to read about euphemistically named "Troubles". In the modern era, Northern Ireland, like Wales, gets a devolved government in Stormont. Unlike Wales, the Northern Ireland government is a total mess, and e.g. they have abortion (like the rest of the UK, and like the rest of Ireland) only because Stormont was so broken that Westminster imposed abortion legalisation on them since they weren't actually governing. If you think the US Congress is dysfunctional, check out Stormont...

Finally Scotland was for a very long time an independent but closely related sovereign nation. It agreed to join this United Kingdom about three hundred years ago in the Acts of Union after about a century with the same Monarch ruling both countries. However, it too got a devolved government, a Parliament, probably the most powerful of the three, in Holyrood, Edingburgh in the 20th century and it has a relatively powerful pro-independence politics, the Scottish National Party is the dominant power in Scottish politics, although how many of its voters actually support independence per se is tricky to judge.

Brexit changed all this again, because as part of the EU a bunch of the powers you could reasonably localise, and so were "devolved" to Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, had been controlled by EU law. So Westminster could say they were devolved, knowing that the constituent entities couldn't actually do much with this supposed power. Having left the EU, those powers were among the thing Brexiteers seemed to have imagined now lay at Westminster, but of course the devolved countries said no, these are our powers, we get to decide e.g. how agricultural subsidies are distributed to suit our farmers.

That's even more fun in Northern Ireland, because they share a border with the Republic, an EU member, and so they're not allowed to have certain rules that would obviously result in a physical border with guards and so on. Their Unionists (the people who are why it isn't just part of the Republic of Ireland because they want to be in the United Kingdom) feel like they were sold out by Westminster politicians, while the Republicans (those who'd rather be part of the Republic) see this as potentially a further argument in favour of that. All of which isn't helping at all to keep the peace between these rivals, that peace being the whole reason we don't want to put up a border...


Most flags use the ISO 2-character country code to access their values. However, some flags don't map to 2-character country codes (Scotland being one example). In this case it uses the sequence black flag, GBSCT (for Great Britain-Scotland, represented using the tag latin small letter codes for the letters) then cancel tag to end the sequence. Changing the middle five to be GBENG gives the English flag and GBWLS gives the Welsh flag.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: