Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Doctors in China been executing prisoners, using their hearts 4 transplantation (twitter.com/mpr0010)
19 points by komuW on April 9, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 4 comments


[flagged]


Why do you think that is a more accurate description of what is happening? The entire point is that the execution is performed by doctors, for the express purpose of organ procurement. You make it sound incidental.


Either way we don't know

So when you want to talk about a subject you don't know, you take the formal route

What do you want to debate with: "Doctors in China been executing prisoners, using their hearts 4 transplantation"? to non chinese audience? "what?? chinese doctors are serial killers? they execute prisoners?"

So you first educate your audience and say: "it's actual death sentenced prisoners since china has Death Penalty"

Now this gives the ability for your audience to be educated about the matter and potentially be offended by Death Penalty

For the second part, it's all linked,

Doctors used that as a way to get prisoners organ, breaching the dead donor rule in China

Now instead of sayin "omg china bad", if you use my proposed title, you get to allow your audience to debate and react about both subjects

- Death Penalty

- Organ procurement abuses by doctors

The original title is biased and doesn't allow any debates, therefore any changes


It’s a perfectly honest title. Doctors in China have been performing live human vivisections. People are being cut open and their living, beating heart is being removed. It does not matter that these people are on death row: what matters is that THEY ARE STILL FUCKING ALIVE WHEN THEIR HEART IS CUT OUT OF THEIR LIVING BODY you sick fuck.


> you sick fuck.

my argumented replies are flagged

but your insult still is not

@dang yo, what's going on at the moderation HQ, are you not reading other people comments? only mine?

i know i hit many nerves with insightful arguments, but that should not give the right to people to insult




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: