A couple of year ago I applied for a graduate position at a prominent Canadian university, and was accepted, based in numerous factors (like publication history, work experience, and academic program). But a few months later, I got a notification that I had been cut: my GPA was too low. My university in Australia didn't even have GPAs back then 1990s-2000s), and it was a very hard marked program (maybe 5% of the class would get over 90%). H3 was a solid pass. But I was competing with people who had just finished undergraduate and master's studies in North America, all of whom had almost perfect A+ GPAs.

The worst part is that it reveals that universities believe their own bullshit. In fact, believing the bs seems to be a strategy for career success.