Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

One could argue that removing the clothes and the overpaint is just as wrong. It bears as a good reminder of the puritan era, of its destructive tendencies, and we are in some way still part of that era. It can also be a good whataboutist example when people are shocked that Taliban destroy the faces of ancient statues. Let's not try to obscure the barbarity of our ways. People who are scared of an uncertain future, trying to conceal the past.


This is a bad argument because it could be used to rationalize preventing any progress whatsoever.


I am not sure what resetting history has to do with progress. I would not be against a new nude statue.


In this case, the progress is “we learned that censoring nude statues is wrong, so we stopped doing it.”

Would keeping slaves as a reminder of the evils of slavery make sense?


That statement applies exactly to both censorship and decensorship.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: