Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think calls for interoperable communication platforms is a good thing!


Sure I do too, but I'm against this ridiculous notion that Apple MUST allow others to integrate and use their services for free.

My point is nobody has any problem with the myriad of other messaging platforms that are completely closed, but all of the sudden iMessage is the bad guy because you don't want to have a green bubble with iPhone users?


A proper thing is for the EU to require apple to implement an interoperabile message api and force that to be used as the default, rather than being able to use a non-interoperable messaging protocol as the default


Like SMS, which is the default right now unless both users are iPhone users?


I don't think anyone's saying apple must allow them (though such people admittedly exist on the internet, in retrospect). I think its more of disappointment at the speed at which apple is "patching" this.


It seems the CEO of Beeper is literally doing that.


As an Apple user, I'm glad they're patching this fast. It's a security issue and privacy one. Sure Beeper may be using it in a non-nefarious way, that doesn't mean bad actors aren't gonna use this to spam the heck out of iMessage users.


You know, I have been getting constant scam texts from "Amazon" for a $289 vacuum that I'm supposed to call a number to cancel the order and it's coming from an email address, or a phone number. Never really got them before in that way.


I've been getting iMessage spam long before Beeper existed.


> My point is nobody has any problem with the myriad of other messaging platforms that are completely closed

That's entirely wrong. A lot of people are angry with every closed messaging platform, which is why people are still maintaining the matrix bridges to Discord, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger and Signal, all of which are still a cat-and-mouse game, violating the ToS of those services.

Those bridges are actually what Beeper Cloud, their primary product, later was also based on.

And these bridges originally are based on the libpurple backends for Slack, Teams, Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp, Signal, AIM, ICQ, Google Chat, Skype, etc, all of which were created through reverse engineering.

So, yeah, fuck those closed services, messages want to be free, and enough people will care that we'll break all of those services.


And they exist. A lot of them, actually.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: