Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The problem with Joe Rogan is that he's not smart and his audience is not smart. He's a pseudo-intellectual. He gifts crackpots an enormous audience of gullible people. He lends credibility to them with softball interviews devoid of critical analysis. He's spoon-feeding suckers what they want to hear. He couches it all in a thin veneer of balanced reporting and barstool philosophizing, under the guise of fairness, but he's elevating ideas that have no business being elevated. It's even worse than outright promotion.


wanting censorship of "unapproved" conversations is objectively worse


If he’s not smart why’s he so successful. Why did he have a job hosting fear factor. A job hosting UFC. A job being a stand up comic. He’s also short - which I thought meant the cards are stacked against you? He also has a black belt. They don’t give those out. He currently has the biggest, arguably most successful podcast of all time.

But he’s not smart right? Years and years of winning but he’s not smart.

You are capable of thinking and you are smart but that doesn’t mean you are right. Don’t conflate the two

How can one conclude he isn’t smart? Are you politically charged against him. Has he wronged you or your loved ones? Would you say he was not ‘smart’ if you had write a report for a 3 Letter agency?

You can get to the top once if you’re lucky. But if you keep ending up there…


> Why did he have a job hosting fear factor. A job hosting UFC

That has no relationship with someone being able to have meaningful discussions on complex topics. Probably even the opposite..


You don’t get a job in front of camera unless you’re good looking or talented. Rogan was not good looking.


He’s certainly talented. However again that has almost bo relationship to being able to have meaningful discussions on highly complex topics.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: