Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

probably so, but crote was talking about external fram chips

the msp430fr4132 you linked costs 160¢ in quantity 35, which is actually considerably cheaper than comparable flash-based chips like the msp430f233 https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/texas-instruments... which is 500¢ in quantity 25. so that's maybe one reason people would use fram: evidently it's cheaper than nor? but i'm pretty sure there are μcs with 8k of nor flash that are cheaper than that and in fact cheaper than the price difference. is this pricing policy some sort of loss leader by ti to drive fram adoption? it seems unlikely. does using fram instead of nor make it cheaper for ti to make the chip? surely 8k of nor couldn't account for such a large cost

on further investigation, i don't find μcs with 8k of nor flash that are cheaper than that, at least in stock at digi-key and still in production. https://www.digikey.com/en/products/filter/embedded/microcon... is the link to my search, which i trust hn will abbreviate in a useful way. but lcsc has the ch32v203 in stock for 39¢ in quantity 100 https://www.lcsc.com/product-detail/Microcontroller-Units-MC... and that has 20k of sram, 64k of flash (presumably nor!), and 24 gpios. that's half the gpios of the ti chip, but i believe my digi-key search linked above was not limited by pin count

so maybe the only reason fram costs more is that ti doesn't license the fram patents to chinese companies? it still beggars belief that ti (and microchip, st, etc.) would be spending three dollars a chip on 8k of nor, or even three dollars a chip divided by two layers of profit margin



AVR64DD14 is $1.20 qty25 for 64kB of Flash and 8kB of SRAM (and quite a bit more analog features, like dual-power supplies, more ACs, DAC, Differential ADC...).

So I'm pretty sure NOR Flash remains quite cheap. TI's MSP430 are all cheapest with FRAM though, so your question is curious. I admit I don't know where to go or how to investigate your question however. I don't really use MSP430 myself, I just know thats what is commonly associated with FRAM in the literature I've read.


huh, I wonder why it wasn't coming up in my search

just as a perspective point on 'quite cheap', nor is still about a thousand times more expensive than nand

i would never buy from ti. they hate hobbyists and have since at least the 70s. they put limor fried on a blacklist




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: