Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Would be nice if links opened a new tab. Good job.


Thanks! I think it's a better practice to not open links in a new tab i.e users should have control over their experience. But it can be subjective.


Think about it this way: Will the user "lose their place" on your page if they click a link and go back? Will the user lose any filtering or search options? If the answer is yes to either, open in a new tab. I personally make this determination all the time, especially on social media after I've scrolled a lot and don't want my "progress" to be lost.


That makes sense to me, thank you. I have changed links to open in a new tab.


Opening in a new tab has become some kind of standard UX. Regardless of that, for this kind of site it would be very useful for product spec comparison.


I’m a Ctrl-click kinda guy for these scenarios.


I think not forcing links to open in a new tab is the right call.

However, the point about losing one's place is a valid one, and I agree with the other commenter that said it would be good to encode the state in the URL to solve that.


Always open in new tab. Ill keep track of the 437 I have open in 7 different FF windows, and the couple Edge tabs to hide cookies ThankYouVeryMuch

EDIT: Yes ctrl-click is too much effort. Middle-click even.

(Many forget a middle click on a mouse-wheel is also a ctrl-click/new-tab button, and the thumb button MOUSE4 is back)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: