I somehow accidentally made you think that I was trying to have a debate about doomers, but I wasn't which is why I prefixed it with "fwiw" (meaning for-what-it's-worth; I'm a random on the internet, so my words aren't worth anything, certainly not worth debating at length) Sorry if I misrepresented my position. To be clear, I have no intense intellectual or emotional investment in doomer ideas nor in criticism of doomer ideas.
Anyway,
> You're definitely mixing things up, and the set of things may include fiction. 2000 years doesn't get you out of the thick disk region of our own galaxy at the speed of light.
Here's what Arthur Breitman wrote[^0] so you can take it up with him, not me:
"
1) [Energy] on planet is more valuable because more immediately accessible.
2) Humans can build AI that can use energy off-planet so, by extension, we are potential consumers of those resources.
3) The total power of all the stars of the observable universe is about 2 × 10^49 W. We consume about 2 × 10^13 W (excluding all biomass solar consumption!). If consumption increases by just 4% a year, there's room for only about 2000 years of growth.
"
About funding:
>> The doomers have also been funded to the tune of half a billion dollars and counting.
> I've never heard such a claim. LessWrong.com has funding more like a few million
"
A young nonprofit [The Future of Life Institute] pushing for strict safety rules on artificial intelligence recently landed more than a half-billion dollars from a single cryptocurrency tycoon — a gift that starkly illuminates the rising financial power of AI-focused organizations.
"
Anyway,
> You're definitely mixing things up, and the set of things may include fiction. 2000 years doesn't get you out of the thick disk region of our own galaxy at the speed of light.
Here's what Arthur Breitman wrote[^0] so you can take it up with him, not me:
"
1) [Energy] on planet is more valuable because more immediately accessible.
2) Humans can build AI that can use energy off-planet so, by extension, we are potential consumers of those resources.
3) The total power of all the stars of the observable universe is about 2 × 10^49 W. We consume about 2 × 10^13 W (excluding all biomass solar consumption!). If consumption increases by just 4% a year, there's room for only about 2000 years of growth.
"
About funding:
>> The doomers have also been funded to the tune of half a billion dollars and counting.
> I've never heard such a claim. LessWrong.com has funding more like a few million
" A young nonprofit [The Future of Life Institute] pushing for strict safety rules on artificial intelligence recently landed more than a half-billion dollars from a single cryptocurrency tycoon — a gift that starkly illuminates the rising financial power of AI-focused organizations. "
---
[^0]: https://x.com/ArthurB/status/1872314309251825849
[^1]: https://www.politico.com/news/2024/03/25/a-665m-crypto-war-c...