Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The Chinese make a full-sized digital model of the human brain. Are they ahead? (arxiv.org)
5 points by madihaa on Jan 6, 2025 | hide | past | favorite | 2 comments


The submission heading should really be changed to the title of the paper:

"Simulation and assimilation of the digital human brain"

Beyond that, they used 14,012 GPUs each with 16GB memory to simulate a human brain, which at retail is what? roughly on the order of $7 Million or so plus a bit for fancy interconnects.

Assume you invest two orders of magnitude more, e.g. $700 million, could you get it to think like a human baby? That's couch cushion money for the FAANGs.

I feel that the only obstacles to full AGI at this point are like the obstacles for getting to the Moon in 1961 - money and a dedicated engineering effort.


At best, they made a digital (aka binary logic) simulation of how they *think* the human brain works.

But every time someone *thinks* they have it all figured out, a new discovery comes along to show they really don't.

You can't simulate what you don't understand. AI is like a modern version of alchemy.

In the same way it is not possible to turn lead into gold using a chemical reaction, it may not be possible or practical to simulate human level intelligence using a digital logic playback device (aka a computer) of a finite, workable size.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: