I did not know you could check them out! But yeah, that really emphasises what I'm saying: there are too many things that are mostly commits but handled in a different way.
And I completely agree that this is about the CLI more than the internal data structures. I pointed at Jujutsu earlier, and that uses Git as the underlying data store (at least in its default configuration). It's an effective strategy in large part because Git-as-a-data-structure works really well already, and the distributed aspect means you can interop very effectively with existing tools like Github just by speaking the right protocol.
But while it keeps much of the same data structures, Jujutsu exposes a very different interface to those data structures, and one that I think is significantly simpler in large part because there aren't so many special cases (such as commits vs staging vs stashes vs ...). You end up with a smaller set of commands, but those commands are more consistent and can be applied in more cases. And you still have staging and stashes, it's just that you can build those yourself more naturally out of the tools that Jujutsu gives you.
And I completely agree that this is about the CLI more than the internal data structures. I pointed at Jujutsu earlier, and that uses Git as the underlying data store (at least in its default configuration). It's an effective strategy in large part because Git-as-a-data-structure works really well already, and the distributed aspect means you can interop very effectively with existing tools like Github just by speaking the right protocol.
But while it keeps much of the same data structures, Jujutsu exposes a very different interface to those data structures, and one that I think is significantly simpler in large part because there aren't so many special cases (such as commits vs staging vs stashes vs ...). You end up with a smaller set of commands, but those commands are more consistent and can be applied in more cases. And you still have staging and stashes, it's just that you can build those yourself more naturally out of the tools that Jujutsu gives you.