Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I have an application that only needs to send E-Mail through my GMail account (git-send-email), another that only needs to write to one specific GMail label (Android SMS Backup)

Maybe you should use throwaway accounts for these purposes? That is, have a gmail account for github to send your patches through, and have that forward to your main email account?

In the SMS-backup case...how important is it that you access your SMSes in your Gmail account? My first thought is: it's bad enough that someone breaks into my email, nevermind all my SMSes. But I guess if you have a workflow that requires easy access to SMSes with your email, you can still have a separate email account that does nothing but forward it onto your main account.

So your main account, theoretically, has strong security with the two-factor authentication without having to make backdoors for external apps. People can always break into your throwaway accounts, but they'll have no particular inroad into your main account.

And presumably, you'd have a decent window of time to detect an intrusion and administer the throwaway accounts with your main GMail account



They should at least go as far as create/read/delete.

Then I can uncheck delete for my chat apps. Edit: And grandparent could uncheck read and delete for a couple of their use cases (which is a pretty big improvement).


AFAIK it is still against Google's policies to have more than one gmail-account? That doesn't mean it won't work, of course, but you might end up with Google turning off all your accounts, with no real recourse to fix the situation.

Why do you need access to your google account to send email from github? From:-headers are designed to be readily "forged" (or rather, set to whatever you want). Just send email through wathever means you use, optionally adding a bcc to your own account, if you want a copy of the actual email in your gmail folder?


Just checked the TOS...it doesn't appear that it's an outright violation to have multiple GMail accounts:

https://mail.google.com/mail/help/intl/en/program_policies.h...

>> Create multiple user accounts in connection with any violation of the Agreement or create user accounts by automated means or under false or fraudulent pretenses

Also, Google gives you the option of managing multiple Google identities from one account.


Yes, I believe you are right -- I can't find any general restrictions against multiple accounts, or service "subscriptions" either. I seem to recall things were different a while back. Now you can apparently create as many google logins as you like, and associate them with (among other services) gmail.

But, after a few minutes of searching, I can't find any actual promises that google will keep neither your logins, nor your services (eg: gmail) operating -- for any reason.

I guess this is worse if you actually pay them money (did they finally come up with a QOS-statement for paid accounts?)...


For me, Android SMS Backup is definitely convenience over security.

However, some type of SMS backup is required: if the Android SMS SQLite db is ever even slightly corrupted (power loss/program crash [usually when db is large]/etc.), Android will silently delete it: http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=10127




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: