> So I reject the notion of throwing the baby out with the bath water as much as the hype bubble around them.
I never mentioned throwing them out; I specifically mentioned that they are niche - they have useful applications in very specific domains.
That use isn't dependent on hype, because they don't need a bunch of investment dollars to somehow find a use-case and create artificial demand.
As an example, someone proposed a while ago that banks could use a blockchain to facilitate near instant foreign exchanges; for the sake of argument let's say that's a feasible thing for them to use it for, and is an improvement over their existing system for them.
The customer doesn't need to know and likely doesn't care that it uses a blockchain to facilitate the transfer. They care that the transfer was much quicker.
Eh, your entire comment was dismissive about the "technologies", and not unlike countless similar reactions about the topic. So any serious points you wanted to make were easy to miss within the sarcasm.
I do agree with your point that valid use cases don't need to rely on hype, but at the same time, the technology that powers it doesn't need to be invisible to users. Some amount of marketing around it shouldn't be an issue. The thing is that we've been flooded with it for the past decade+, and the critical thinking public has become desensitized to the bullshit. But this doesn't mean that underneath that there is zero legitimate value, as some people vocally claim.
I never mentioned throwing them out; I specifically mentioned that they are niche - they have useful applications in very specific domains.
That use isn't dependent on hype, because they don't need a bunch of investment dollars to somehow find a use-case and create artificial demand.
As an example, someone proposed a while ago that banks could use a blockchain to facilitate near instant foreign exchanges; for the sake of argument let's say that's a feasible thing for them to use it for, and is an improvement over their existing system for them.
The customer doesn't need to know and likely doesn't care that it uses a blockchain to facilitate the transfer. They care that the transfer was much quicker.