Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It still takes few seconds per target with technologies available right now. That's likely the reason why an operational anti drone laser turret is not a thing yet.


> operational anti drone turret is not a thing yet.

I’ve read about a bunch of these systems even if they aren’t in widespread deployment some are still being tested in real world conditions.

What about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silent_Hunter_(laser_weapon)

“The Silent Hunter has been used by Saudi Arabia to guard against Houthi drones and missiles.”

“During the World Defense Show in Riyadh the February 05, 2024, Poly Technologies announced the first hard-kill engagement of a one-way attack drone.[6]”


Again, it takes few seconds per target with current laser tech. Which means they don't have important simultaneous multi target engagement capability.

The targets, whether it's plumbing pipe rockets or lipo drones, come in at 100-1000 yards/sec, so you don't really have that many seconds per target.

They work in the demo in which you just shoot down the sole target as it fly perpendicular to the machine for both physical and career safety, but when it comes to deploying the thing around your bed, guns make a lot more sense.


The quotes suggest that system has actually been deployed and used successfully in real world conditions.

Also, your objection doesn’t really fit how drones have been used. Massive highly coordinated drone swarms are extremely unusual, the threat is mostly individual drones or small clusters.

Many very dangerous drones are well under 100y/s aka 200mph.

1000 yards/second aka Mach 2.7 is well beyond the ‘drones’ people are concerned with and into expensive missile territory. Which is where anti missile systems get used.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: