Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ahead of time, and from the inside, it looks and sounds like 'restoring proper order'.

Afterwards, and from the outside, it looks and sounds like ... well read some history about attempts to 'restore proper order'. The outcome and progression is entirely and sadly predictable.

It's been about 80 years since WWII. Are we doomed to repeat this on an 80 year cycle, when the last generation who went through this passes from the scene?



Yes. AFAIK, this is exactly the (theoretical) cause for the "doomed to repeat it" effect of "those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it" - the death of the last generation who remembers it from the previous iteration.

So - maybe not doomed to an 80 year cycle, as life expectancy changes, and/or as cultural memory changes due to more/better records.

But in broad strokes... yes.


> Are we doomed to repeat this on an 80 year cycle, when the last generation who went through this passes from the scene?

Have fun reading about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generatio...


Been thinking about this a lot lately.


As someone who got advice when I was younger and got older; I think we are doomed to not learn anything from history. This might explain the persistence of religion: Here are a set of rules that kind of worked, just follow them blindly and religiously.

The current US generation didn't go to a full blown war; and the US did little infighting in the previous decade (that requires mass mobilization). Think about it this way: Trump wants to lower the interest rate and ease monetary policy in good times. Putin maintain high rates despite him having a full blown war. Trump has never experienced hyper-inflation but Putin did.


Enforcing immigration laws is a repetition of WWII?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: