Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


What do you propose to replace those institutions? The needs thereof do not go away. For-profits in the private sector? Are they going to be feeding Gazans?

You don’t fix a house’s plumbing by detonating a bomb under the foundation.


Privatizing government institutions won't do anything to help, but it is nonetheless the case that the American government has a large amount of responsibility for what's going on. The reason why American companies cannot simply sell food to Gaza is because the government of Israel controls access to Gaza and the government of America supports them in this.

Without the American government's various anti-BDS laws, it would be much easier for American organizations to apply pressure to Israel to stop their genocide. Furthermore, without the American government providing support for Israel, they'd be in a much tighter spot and would face significantly stronger incentives to stop.


…sell food to Gaza? The people of Gaza have little way to buy food right now. Gaza does not possess a hoard of wealth to trade to private companies for food et al, just lying in wait for Israel’s violence to cease.

I agree that the American government is complicit but private industry is no less complicit.

Capital wants to remove the population of Gaza and turn it into beachside real estate. This much has been said out loud by the very people who are acting to hollow out the government.


The economic circumstance of Gaza is a consequence of Israel's genocidal policies, and removing the population of Gaza is the goal of Israel, not ""Capital"".

Smack down Israel and their American sycophants and food and investments will both start flowing into Gaza.


> I won’t cry if it is dismantled.

You will if the private replacement is much worse.


The federal government is 36 trillion in debt. How do you run things worse than that? No private company or citizen would survive blowing up their finances as bad as what the federal government has been doing for decades.


Most folks with a mortgage are in a similar spot - long term debt at low rates in excess of annual income - and we can’t print money.

Government isn’t a business. It can’t declare bankruptcy and it can’t price half the country out of the market.

If you’re really a deficit hawk, this admin should be appalling to you.


It does


The government is not a company. It is ludicrous to expect it to operate like one.


I’d say it is ludicrous to be okay with them continually eroding our buying power with inflationary spending.

You’re right it isn’t a company. Its actions directly impact all of us whether we want to do business with them or not.


I don’t know that. I do know that this one was terrible though.


The current administration is fully on Israel's side of the conflict.


As was the last one - which I believe was a significant part of OP's point. Neither side represents us.


[flagged]


I'm inclined to see quite a bit of agency in the hands of both the US and Israel. The US absolutely can and should be doing more to pressure their ally, who they provide both very significant monetary and diplomatic support to.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: