Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Their strategy is and has been for decades to kill as many Palestinians as possible.

This is just obviously false, Israel obviously has the military capability to kill effectively every Palestinian in Gaza, and yet they make significant efforts to prevent civilian casualties there.



It's more accurate to say "as many Palestinians as they thought the US would let them get away with". This is why each new kind of atrocity was first messaged and checked with the US before proceeding. Without cover in the UN and unlimited bombs from the US Israel's actions in Gaza would not have been possible.

Folks may remember when Israel thought they had to cook up a bunch of fancy 3D renders of a "Hamas command center" and do a multi-week propaganda blitz before attacking Al Shifa hospital. Then they eventually realized that the Biden administration didn't care, nor did they care about the lack of evidence for this supposed massive complex [1] after the fact. So they could bomb hospitals with just a generic justification after the fact.

It was the same with every escalation, from murdering UN aid workers to dropping 2,000lb bombs on tents to completely flattening cities they had designated as "safe zones".

Israel would push the envelope a bit, see that their key patron didn't care, and push it further. What was once a line they feared to cross became the new normal.

[1] It turned out to just be a couple hospital rooms that a former Israeli PM admitted they themselves had built.

https://www.newsweek.com/israel-built-bunker-shifa-hospital-...


> It's more accurate to say "as many Palestinians as they thought the US would let them get away with". This is why each new kind of atrocity was first messaged and checked with the US before proceeding. Without cover in the UN and unlimited bombs from the US Israel's actions in Gaza would not have been possible.

Israel makes far more efforts than even the US when it comes to trying to prevent civilian casualties.

> Folks may remember when Israel thought they had to cook up a bunch of fancy 3D renders of a "Hamas command center" and do a multi-week propaganda blitz before attacking Al Shifa hospital. Then they eventually realized that the Biden administration didn't care, nor did they care about the lack of evidence for this supposed massive complex [1] after the fact. So they could bomb hospitals with just a generic justification after the fact.

There's plenty of evidence Hamas used Al Shifa for military purposes, although it's maybe somewhat unclear to what extent exactly. Also from my understanding Israel didn't bomb Al Shifa, they raided it instead.

> It was the same with every escalation, from murdering UN aid workers to dropping 2,000lb bombs on tents to completely flattening cities they had designated as "safe zones".

The entire Gaza strip is a war zone, Israel largely tries to avoid combat operations in the al-Mawasi humanitarian zone but that doesn't mean Hamas has complete immunity there[0].

> [1] It turned out to just be a couple hospital rooms that a former Israeli PM admitted they themselves had built.

Regardless of who built the bunker under the hospital if Hamas uses it for military purposes that makes the hospital a valid military target. I'm not sure how a bunker having been built by Israel decades ago would make a difference in regards to it being a valid military target or not.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13_July_2024_al-Mawasi_attack


> …and yet they make significant efforts to prevent civilian casualties there.

This is just obviously false. All you have to do is look at how many children they’ve killed. Those aren’t the number of someone going out of their way to prevent civilian casualties.

It’s 50,000 children by the way. https://www.unicefusa.org/stories/more-50000-children-killed...


lol... bots are up in arm. No one with two brain cells believes this, anymore. The only reason they are not just straight nuking the places (both gaza and west bank), because of external pressures. They would if they could.


> The only reason they are not just straight nuking the places (both gaza and west bank), because of external pressures. They would if they could.

They clearly would not, there are significant domestic political pressures to minimize civilian casualties regardless of external pressures.


The level of mental gymnastics to believe the state of Israel has done anything but active genocide for decades is astounding.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: