Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why should wikipedia fold? Can any country put any legitimate pressure against them for just listing a domain.


Linking to illegal services can be illegal, that’s why.


> Linking to illegal services can be illegal, that’s why.

What is illegal in one country can be illegal everywhere.

I don't remember Wikipedia removing LGBTIAQ++ articles just because that's illegal in Iran.

If a government thinks Wikipedia is illegal in their country, they can force local ISP providers to block it, but it's not Wikipedia's responsibility [1] to censor itself.

[1] at least should not be


The Wikimedia Foundation is a US corporation. There are national chapters in some other countries, which are corporations in the respective country. The internet isn't the Wild West; websites are subject to the laws of the countries they operate in.

They can also just create a new foundation elsewhere if the US becomes hostile.

What country does Anna’s archive operate in?

No it's not, at least in US. Google fought and won this case.

Countries can pressure them for many reasons, fairly or not. Under pressure, Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales interfered with a page about the war in Gaza (though I don't know th outcome of that).

Why should registrar/ISP fold?

It's not that they should, they often do though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: