Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


We don't know that, and we don't know that neanderthal males were more prone to rape than homo sapiens males. And it's weird to even apply the 21st century concept of rape to prehistoric societies.


I have to agree, theres a bizarre and worrying internet-brained hysterical element to that original comment which betrays a totally absent education.

the casual title is because of the scientific and prehistoric nature of the subject


However, if one happens to be a race science type, there’s a lot of profit that can be made telling suggestive “just so” stories about which homo sapiens genetic lines are allegedly tainted with a larger proportion of neanderthal genes, or however that’s supposed to work.


It would be an afrocentric trope because it’s Europeans that have the most neanderthal genes.


https://wwnorton.com/books/9781324091455/

Fantasizing about prehistory to justify contemporary racism is a very old pastime. It doesn’t aspire to logical consistency:

> From the “state of nature” and Romantic notions of virtuous German barbarians to theories about Neanderthals, killer apes, and a matriarchal paradise where women ruled, Geroulanos captures the sheer variety and strangeness of the ideas that animated many of the major thinkers of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, including Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Charles Darwin, and Karl Marx. Yet as Geroulanos shows, such ideas became, for the most part, the ideological foundations of repressive regimes and globe-spanning empires. Deeming other peoples “savages” allowed for guilt-free violence against them; notions of “killer apes” who were our evolutionary predecessors made war seem natural. The emergence of modern science only accelerated the West’s imperialism. The Nazi obsession with race was rooted in archaeological claims about prehistoric IndoGermans; the idea that colonialized peoples could be “bombed back to the Stone Age” was made possible by the technology of flight and the anthropological idea that civilization advanced in stages.


Wrong, East Asians have.

And South Asians have nearly same as Europeans.


And because Europeans have the most Neanderthal genes, it's all "Neanderthals are smarter than we thought!" and not "are Europeans the missing link?"


> neanderthal males were raping homo sapiens females.

I guess you'd rather not even be here?


Or that during the migration men died or were captured and killed.


>neanderthal males were raping homo sapiens females. Neanderthals had much higher muscle mass and were much stronger than homo sapiens.

It's quite possible that at that point in time nobody was asking for permission and most sex would have been what we qualify today as rape.


Amor Fati. The idea that we would carry ontological guilt for prehistoric sex acts that happened further up our family tree is just... masochistic. Not to mention that our ancestors would be both perpetrator and victim?

I understand the instinct to virtue signal but no good can come from this.


> the differential is because neanderthal males were raping homo sapiens females

They were simply more attractive to homo sapiens females because of more chest hair, muscles, and better defined jawline.


Well, ya. Of course it was rape. And in retaliation we genocided them, hence the lack of Y and mRNA.


> and mRNA

This might be seen as a bit of a nitpick but I believe you mean mtDNA (mitochondrial).


>And in retaliation we genocided them

This is far from being the only or even main explanation to their extinction.

The Neanderthal populations were extremely inbred, so I'd guess that was a bigger factor to their decline.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: