Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I watch movies and I'll watch TV shows ... There's plenty of creativity in the real world

You realize that movies and TV shows most certainly do not constitute the "real world"?

Nobody says you have to read fiction. But it's really a shame to take the weaker forms of escapism the world has to offer you rather than the deeper, ecstatic ones, just because the latter are in book form.



I don't think he's taking "weaker" forms of escapism as he's taking shorter ones.

I still find his stance different as a lover of fiction, but I can't argue that a good book isn't also very time consuming, and if you allow that your time is precious, there are probably better uses for it.


I think TV shows and movies are weaker. Movies can't do what books can do because you don't create them in your mind as you consume them (or at least not in the same way).

But I can see why for some people, the basic realism of film might take them even further than a book and their own imagination. My original post sounded a bit more judgmental than intended.


I share your viewpoint. Like Fried, I don't read fiction novels either but.. I do read short stories from time to time. Especially J G Ballard.

It's all about the time issue for me. I read lots of long novels as a teen but it's either do that or actually do some work nowadays.

As an aside, the death of the short story as a significant literary force is worth mourning here too..


He is most definitely not speaking like TV and movies are the real world as your quote seems to make out. I also tend to stay away from fiction other than the occasional short story and find that autobiographies and other forms of non-fiction offer a nice creative boost in their writing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: